Tuesday, 5 June 2012

Rural GP's outperforming urban GP's in east Lancashire

In response to several enquiries in Hyndburn about GP's, the PCT and soon to be Clinical Commissioning Group have published online GP scorecards for East Lancashire rating each GP practice.
You can see from the PCT's data that GP's in the rural areas offer a much better service than those in urban areas. Hyndburn's GP scorecards are particularly disappointing.  
I have spoken with the CCG about this and they assure me everything is being done to improve the GP scorecards for urban east Lancashire. 
Please find below the final headline version of the Practice Development Framework: GP Scorecard for 2010/11. The Scorecard can be viewed as a full document (follow link below) covering all GP practices within NHS East Lancashire. Alternatively, the Scorecard can be viewed by the following localities:


Link
http://www.eastlancspct.nhs.uk/about-us/publications/gp-scorecard/

Obviously it is disappointing that Hyndburn GP's have lower scores and I have raised this matter on several occasions with the PCT and now the new GP's CCG. They assure me much is being done to raise standards including GP's moving into better facilities in the Acorn and Accrington Pals centres.


Constituency
Practice
2009/10
2010/11
improvement
1
Ribble Valley
Sabden & Whalley Medical Centre
90
95
105.6%
2
Ribble Valley
Pendleside Medical Practice
87.5
93
106.3%
3
Burnley
Yorkshire Street Medical Centre
87.5
92
105.1%
4
Burnley
Drs Barsby & Kallarackel
82.5
92
111.5%
5
Pendle
Earby Surgery
80
92
115.0%
6
Burnley
Parkside Surgery
80
89
111.3%
7
Burnley
Oxford Road Medical Centre
82.5
88
106.7%
8
Pendle
Colne Corner Surgery
77.5
88
113.5%
9
Burnley
Thursby Surgery
82.5
86
104.2%
10
Ribble Valley
Slaidburn Country Practice
80
86
107.5%
11
Hyndburn
Dr Agarwal
80
85
106.3%
12
Ribble Valley
Castle Medical Practice
87.5
85
97.1%
13
Burnley
Ightenhill Medical Centre
67.5
83
123.0%
14
Hyndburn
Kusum Medical Centre
67.5
83
123.0%
15
Pendle
Whitefield Health Care
67.5
83
123.0%
16
Rossendale
Waterfoot Group of Doctors
75
83
110.7%
17
Ribble Valley
Berry Lane Medical Centre
82.5
82
99.4%
18
Rossendale
Dr Rishton & Partners
75
82
109.3%
19
Burnley
Rosegrove Surgery
80
81
101.3%
20
Rossendale
Whitworth Medical Centre
62.5
80
128.0%
21
Rossendale
Drs Moujaes & Mannan
55
80
145.5%
22
Rossendale
St James Medical Centre
75
79
105.3%
23
Burnley
Rosehill Surgery
80
78
97.5%
24
Rossendale
Rossendale Valley Medical Practice
60
78
130.0%
25
Burnley
Briercliffe Surgery
62.5
77
123.2%
26
Rossendale
Irwell Medical Practice
70
76
108.6%
27
Burnley
Colne Road Surgery
60
74
123.3%
28
Pendle
Dr Jehangir
60
74
123.3%
29
Ribble Valley
Stonebridge Surgery
70
74
105.7%
30
Burnley
Burnley Wood Medical Centre
57.5
73
127.0%
31
Hyndburn
Great Harwood Medical Group
65
73
112.3%
32
Pendle
Dr Jha
70
73
104.3%
33
Burnley
Manchester Road Surgery
60
72
120.0%
34
Burnley
Padiham Group Practice
50
72
144.0%
35
Pendle
Harambee Surgery
65
72
110.8%
36
Hyndburn
Myrtle House
52.5
71
135.2%
37
Pendle
Pendle View Medical Centre
45
71
157.8%
38
Hyndburn
Dr Joseph
55
70
127.3%
39
Hyndburn
The Cabin Surgery
70
70
100.0%
40
Pendle
Reedyford Health Care Group
60
69
115.0%
41
Burnley
Ruskin Health Care
67.5
68
100.7%
42
Hyndburn
Oswald Medical Centre
57.5
68
118.3%
43
Hyndburn
King Street Medical Centre
60
68
113.3%
44
Pendle
Pendle Valley Practice
55
68
123.6%
45
Pendle
Horsfield Practice
70
68
97.1%
46
Rossendale
Fairmore Medical Practice
N/A
68
#VALUE!
47
Burnley
St Nicholas Group Practice
57.5
66
114.8%
48
Hyndburn
Dr Kapenda
37.5
65
173.3%
49
Pendle
Drs Malik & Umar
42.5
65
152.9%
50
Rossendale
Ilex View Medical Practice
62.5
65
104.0%
51
Hyndburn
Dr Royle
70
64
91.4%
52
Pendle
Barnoldswick Medical Centre
70
64
91.4%
53
Hyndburn
Clayton Medical Centre
40
62
155.0%
54
Hyndburn
Peel House Medical Practice
50
60
120.0%
55
Pendle
Millside Surgery
57.5
60
104.3%
56
Pendle
Barrowford Surgery
65
58
89.2%
57
Pendle
Brierfield Health Centre
57.5
56
97.4%
58
Hyndburn
Dr Bhat
55
52
94.5%
59
Hyndburn
Eagle Medical Practice
45
51
113.3%
60
Hyndburn
Richmond Medical Centre
42.5
50
117.6%
61
Hyndburn
Dr Ahmed
52.5
50
95.2%
62
Hyndburn
Accrington Victoria HAC
N/A
49
#VALUE!
63
Pendle
Richmond Court Group Practice
45
49
108.9%
64
Burnley
Daneshouse Medical Centre
40
47
117.5%
65
Pendle
The Hill Top Surgery
47.5
47
98.9%
66
Hyndburn
Dr Motupalli
50
44
88.0%
67
Hyndburn
Drs Valluri
40
41
102.5%